4 Best Harley Davidson Primary Oil Substitute: [Full Reviews]

Owning a Harley is like being a king on the road. But that comes with some responsibilities. For example, you need to make sure the best lubricants for the bike’s engine, transmission, and primary.

Sometimes, it can’t be possible to manage different oil for 3 different parts. So, we have researched and reviewed the best Harley Davidson primary oil substitutes that are available all over the country.

Spoiler alert: you can use any synthetic oil without friction modifiers that we use as engine oils or transmission fluids. Among hundreds of options, you may get confused and choose the wrong oil. So, read the review and select one that your favorite ride’s primary deserves.

Here are our honest recommendations on best Harley Davidson primary oil substitutes:

  1. Best ATF: Bel-Ray Big Twin Transmission Oil
  2. Runner-Up ATF: Spectro Oil R.HDPG6 Heavy Duty Platinum Full Synthetic 6spd Trans Lube
  3. Best Engine Oil: Mobil 1 96936 20W-50 V-Twin Synthetic Motorcycle Motor Oil
  4. Runner-Up Engine Oil: Castrol 06116 POWER1 V-TWIN 4T 20W-50 Synthetic Motorcycle Oil

What Are The Best Harley Davidson Primary Oil Substitute Types?

The first and best substitute is using synthetic oil for the engine. That means the recommended 20W-50 rated oil is the best option for any Harley Davidson model out there.

However, according to some experts, it is also an excellent option to use the transmission fluid as a primary oil. If you are looking for a safe bet, go for the engine oil. The fact is that solving noise problems in the primary requires synthetic transmission oils.

In summary, you can use engine oil or transmission fluid as Harley primary oil substitutes. Both are completely safe for the chaincase as lots of people have shared their experiences in Harley forums.

Primary Oil Change Accessories You May Need

  1. Crankcase Fill Funnel Primary Case
  2. TCMT Low Profile Oil Drain Pan
  3. OEMTOOLS 22346 5/8 Inch SAE Deep Socket
  4. CHANNELLOCK T27 x 4 In. Torx Screwdriver
  5. 50-Replacement (BLACK) VITON O-rings

Best Harley Davidson Primary Oil Substitute – The Review

1. Best ATF: Bel-Ray Big Twin Transmission Oil

Bel-Ray 96900-BT1 Gear Oils
146 Reviews
Bel-Ray 96900-BT1 Gear Oils
  • Superior lubricity minimizes sliding friction for maximum power.
  • Use in combination with Bel-Ray V-Twin Synthetic Motor Oil for maximum performance
  • Special lubricity additives provide for exceptionally smooth and quiet shifting

Bel-Ray Big Twin Transmission Oil is best for minimizing sliding friction. It also has a higher viscosity or thickness to ensure quiet shifting. So, if your Harley’s primary has been making some noises recently, it will work like magic to solve that.

The special lubricity additives and the viscosity rating are responsible for that smooth and noise-free performance. The making of Bel-Ray Big Twin Transmission Oil prevents viscosity breakdown from ensuring performance in harsh conditions.

The formulation is specifically made for motorcycle uses that can protect against wear. Big Harley engines are air-cooled, and this lubricant is great for such cooling systems. So, you can rely on its 85W-140 rating without any doubt.

Why is it our first choice as in the ATF category?

Basically, there are no big differences between the best and runner-up products. Considering overall performance and features, you can get Bel-Ray for a more reasonable price. So, consult with your mechanic and make the final move on the best Harley primary oil alternative.

Summary: The transmission fluid from Bel-Ray is convenient for the chaincase as it doesn’t have friction modifiers. Expert mechanics recommend the oil for its thickness and performance that the chaincase would surely love.

Pros

  • Increases the life of the primary chaincase
  • Prevents clunking
  • Reduces noise

Cons

  • Not so great in very cold weathers

2. Runner-Up ATF: Spectro Oil R.HDPG6 Heavy Duty Platinum Full Synthetic 6spd Trans Lube

Spectro Oil R.HDPG6 Heavy Duty Platinum Full Synthetic 6spd Trans Lube 1 Quart
102 Reviews
Spectro Oil R.HDPG6 Heavy Duty Platinum Full Synthetic 6spd Trans Lube 1 Quart
  • Cures noisy six speed transmissions
  • Smoother shifting, reduces fifth gear whine and eliminates clunks
  • G4 technology, special additives that provide additional anti-wear protection, higher film strength between the gears, and reduces drag while extending gear life
  • High loads and extreme heat do not affect the oil
  • A.P.I. Gl-5 rated. Dyed Red. Exceeds all known OEM and Harley Davidson warranty requirements

Have you got a Harley 6-speed noisy transmission system? Don’t worry about the noise anymore as the Spectro Oil R.HDPG6 comes with the necessary additives to solve the problem.

The full synthetic ATF is highly capable of ensuring smooth shifting and wear caused by friction. From the SAE rating of this oil, 75W-140, you would understand that the lubricant works perfectly in harsh weather conditions.

Lots of Harley users complain about the whining in the fifth gear and clunking. If you face the same issues, don’t wait and buy this one after discussing a little with your mechanic. However, there is a little issue regarding the price as it increases maintenance costs significantly.

Why should I consider this expensive tranny oil?

If you live in a colder region, this 75W-140 rated synthetic ATF will outperform the top pick. So, don’t depend on the price tag for making a decision where the weather is a big concern.

Summary: For 6-speed transmissions and the requirement for riding in the cold, you won’t find a better Harley primary oil substitute than Spectro Oil R.HDPG6. It has the right level of viscosity and balanced formula to support transmission as well as primary.

Pros

  • Increases the gear life
  • Almost zero noise
  • Ratings exceed warranty requirements
  • Suitable for both hot and cold weather

Cons

  • Expensive

3. Best Engine Oil: Mobil 1 96936 20W-50 V-Twin Synthetic Motorcycle Motor Oil

Sale
Mobil 1 96936 20W-50 V-Twin Synthetic Motocycle Motor Oil - 1 Quart (Pack of 6)
896 Reviews
Mobil 1 96936 20W-50 V-Twin Synthetic Motocycle Motor Oil - 1 Quart (Pack of 6)
  • For best performance, follow the manufacturer's recommendations in your vehicle owner’s manual.

If you are already using Mobile 1 20W-50 V-Twin Synthetic oil for the engine, you won’t have to suffer from indecision. Use the same oil in the primary, and the chaincase would perform without making noise.

Some manufacturers ensure the perfect balance of additives so that all three parts of a motorcycle can be lubricated simultaneously. Those who think arranging three different oils for engine, transmission, and primary is not practical can have Mobile 1.

It is a perfectly balanced lubricant that is manufactured, matching the conditions in an air-cooled engine. So, your Harley indeed would love the formula. Within the higher temperature range, the oil performs well, preventing wear.

Its low-temperature performance is also satisfactory. One big advantage is that the lubricant keeps the engine clean from debris. For 4-stroke engines, it has a balanced formulation to increase the gears’ life and other parts.

Can I confidently consider Mobile 1 as a Harley primary oil alternative?

Yes, you can. However, experts may argue ATF is better than motor oil as a substitute considering viscosity and other ratings. But the convenience is more in engine oil as you can buy one type and pour it into all three holes.

Summary: With some of the house’s best brains, ExxonMobil has created the perfect engine oil for Harley bikes. The company recommends the lubricant for transmission and primary also for its capabilities.

Pros

  • Improves performance
  • Increases service life
  • Ensures easy starting
  • Makes bikes quieter

Cons

  • Not suitable for other than Harley bikes

4. Runner-Up Engine Oil: Castrol 06116 POWER1 V-TWIN 4T 20W-50 Synthetic Motorcycle Oil

Castrol 06116 POWER1 V-TWIN 4T 20W-50 Synthetic Motorcycle Oil, 1 Quart Bottle, 6 Pack
1,311 Reviews
Castrol 06116 POWER1 V-TWIN 4T 20W-50 Synthetic Motorcycle Oil, 1 Quart Bottle, 6 Pack
  • For best performance, follow the manufacturer's recommendations in your vehicle owner’s manual.
  • Formulated with Trizone technology to protect all 3 critical zones: engine, clutch and gearbox
  • Race derived technology for maximum engine acceleration
  • Extreme high temperature air-cooled performance
  • Excellent shear stability to prevent viscosity breakdown

The trust people have on the Mobile and Amsoil engine oils are almost the same for Castrol POWER1. The manufacturer has ensured that it has the perfect additives for motorcycles proven in the race tracks.

You would know that the oil is fully synthetic and doesn’t contain special friction modifiers from the documentation. So, you can use the same oil for your engine, transmission, and primary chaincase.

The features and performance are almost the same as Mobile 1. That is why we won’t be discussing those in detail. Castrol uses their proprietary Trizone technology so that it can be used in all Harley models.

Castrol POWER1 has performance capabilities like the Mobil1, but we had to select it for some Harley owners’ issues.

Summary: Perfect formulation with the necessary additives that work well on the racing bikes can be the piece of information you need. Get POWER1 to increase the life of your Harley’s engine, and other parts.

Pros

  • Good wear protection
  • Great cooling capabilities
  • Balanced blend proven on race bikes

Cons

  • Reported issues on some models

How To Change Primary Oil In Harley?

The following process applies to all Harley Davidson models except the Sportster. But you must check the owner’s manual that is specific for your bike model. It would show you the specs and exact procedures to change primary case oil. Now, let’s begin the process.

Step 1: Make the bike stand straight up and down so that the fluid can pass easily.

Step 2: Now, remove the cover of the chaincase along with its gasket.

Step 3: After that, remove the drain plug using the right tool and collect it in a plastic tray. In the meantime, clean the drain plug and remove debris from its magnetic tip.

Step 4: Next, replace the rubber o-ring on the drain plug if necessary. Also, wrap up some Teflon tape on the top, and tighten it in its place.

Step 5: Finally, use a crankcase fill funnel to fill the housing and don’t put too much oil than the recommendation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can you use motor oil in Harley primary?

Yes, it is okay to use motor or engine oil in the primary as long as it is full synthetic with the right blend. But synthetic engine oil with friction modifiers is not recommended by the experts.

What is the Harley Davidson primary oil capacity?

Generally speaking, the primary oil capacity of a Harley Davidson is 1 quart or 32 ounces. However, check your owner’s manual and don’t do guesswork.

Conclusion

So, could you select the best Harley Davidson primary oil substitute from our reviewed products? Both alternatives have pros and cons, but the ultimate decision depends on your requirements.

The best Harley Davidson primary oil substitute would be the transmission fluids because they have higher viscosity ratings and can withstand a wide range to temperature. Even though they cost more, you can select the one from Bel-Ray if it is freezing in your area.

On the other hand, buying engine oil is also relevant as you won’t have to look for different options every time. Get Mobile 1 from your local shops or order on Amazon for a smooth and noiseless ride.